Lizzie Borden Took an Axe; How Gender Roles and Socioeconomic Privilege in Victorian Massachusetts Influenced the Trial of Lizzie A. Borden
In 1892, when authorities arrested Lizzie Borden for the brutal axe-murders of her father and stepmother, America, and specifically Massachusetts, stood at the forefront of the Women's Suffrage Movement. Several of the first conventions, halls, and clubs in support of the movement took place in Lizzie’s home state of Massachusetts. In this paper I will examine how the gender roles and socioeconomic factors of Victorian Massachusetts contributed to Lizzie Borden’s acquittal despite the abundance of circumstantial evidence. I will not argue for Lizzie’s innocence, as I believe she committed the crime, but instead I will present how the gender norms and socioeconomic factors of this era shaped perceptions of criminality and public opinion.
Although the United States was in the midst of the Women’s Suffrage Movement, Congress and the states would not ratify the 19th Amendment until almost thirty years after the Borden murders. Lizzie existed in a time where gender roles became distinctly defined, as it became less frequent for women to work alongside male family members in the field or family business, and more common for them to adorn a large hoop-skirt, passing their days in the home. Lizzie embodied the ideals of Victorian womanhood, maintaining the reserved demeanor expected of women of her era throughout her trial.
Another element of the Borden case that further solidified Lizzie as a righteous and refined Victorian woman was her family’s wealth. Her father, Andrew Borden, had amassed a great deal of capital over the years, affording Lizzie the opportunities and social status of an upper-middle-class woman of her era. Given her social position and the traditionalist nature of Fall River, Massachusetts in 1892, her community did not want to believe a demure woman of her status could commit such a horrid crime. Lizzie exemplified the dignity, piousness, and polished nature of the modern Victorian woman. Contemporary historians have described her as plain, well-bred, and unremarkable. Historians have stated that Lizzie embodied Victorian ideals of femininity. She was active in her community, within her church, and she played the correct role of a woman of her time, checking all the boxes of what was expected of her.
What would it mean to charge a woman of this stature and reputation? To indict her for the double murder of her father and stepfather would challenge the very foundation upon which Victorian society built its understanding of gender roles and morality. She simply could not be convicted of these crimes because her community could not reconcile the image of a well-regarded Victorian woman with the brutality of this crime. We must also consider that only men served on her jury, as women could not serve as jurors until the 1950s. This was not merely a case about reasonable doubt, but rather a case about unreasonable certainty. It was simply impossible and too upsetting to believe that a woman of Lizzie’s nature, stature, and standing would have committed this grisly crime, given the circumstances and norms of the time period. It was simply easier and more sound for Lizzie’s community to dismiss the evidence than to believe she committed this heinous crime.