Stupid Sexy Sauron: Essays on Tolkien’s Transformative Dark Lord

deadline for submissions: 
December 31, 2026
full name / name of organization: 
Danna Petersen-Deeprose and Robinson Jay Ensz

The Dark Lord Sauron, the titular Lord of the Rings in Tolkien’s magnum opus, plays many roles and takes many forms throughout The Lord of the Rings, The Silmarillion, and the rest of Tolkien’s Legendarium, and even more in the various adaptations and reimaginings that have since emerged. Over years of varying interpretations, Sauron has evolved into a figure of vast significance. From his early depictions as a looming, disembodied threat to his more recent portrayals as a visually captivating "sexy" villain in contemporary pop culture, Sauron’s image has undergone a transformation, revealing much about changing attitudes toward power, corruption, and desire.  

We are seeking essays that explore the various ways Sauron has been interpreted, depicted, and reimagined across literature, film, television, video games, and fan culture. We invite contributions that engage with the following themes, though submissions are not limited to these topics:

  • Sauron as a Character: How can we read Sauron’s role in The Lord of the Rings? How can he be interpreted on the level of character, and what are the thematic implications involved? How can we interpret Sauron's relationships with other characters (Frodo, Saruman, Shelob, the Mouth of Sauron, the Witchking, etc.)? How does the characterization of Sauron shift in the other stories of Tolkien’s Legendarium?
  • Power and Corruption: What can Sauron tell us about the nature of power, corruption, and evil in the works of Tolkien? What would it yield to approach Sauron’s lust for power and domination through the lens of feminist reading, post-colonial reading, and other contemporary critical theories and methodologies? 
  • Queering Sauron: To what extent is Sauron depicted in the text as queer (in all senses of the word)? What can we learn about the character and text if we approach the character of Sauron through the lens of queer literary theory? In what ways can non-normative readings challenge traditional understandings of Sauron’s power, gender, and relationships? What can the "queering" of Sauron reveal about themes of desire, control, and fluidity in his character?
  • Film and Media Adaptations: From the animated films of the 1970s to The Rings of Power, how has the visual representation of Sauron changed over time? How do these adaptations juxtapose with the Sauron of Tolkien’s texts?
  • Fan Culture and Interpretations: How have fan interpretations of Sauron in art, tabletop games (e.g. Magic the Gathering or TTRPGs), fanfiction, and other media contributed to his evolving image? How does this challenge or expand Tolkien’s textual portrayal of the character?
  • Medieval Villainy and Mythic Archetypes: How does Sauron fit within the medieval tradition? What elements of The Lord of the Rings reflect a more traditional, mythic interpretation of villainy?
  • Literary Descendants and Comparative Reading: Compare Sauron, both in Tolkien’s original work and in adaptations and fanworks, to characters from other stories and genres. What can it yield to read Sauron alongside villains from literary fiction, science fiction, and other genres, or alongside villainous or morally gray characters from romance and romantasy? What can the rise in popularity of powerful, villainous romantic leads and the archetype of the so-called “Shadow Daddy” (see A Court of Thorns and Roses, Fourth Wing, etc.) tell us about the rise in romantic readings of Sauron (see Rings of Power and the history of Sauron/Celebrimbor romantic fanfiction)? 

The proposed collection is intended to be scholarly but accessible in tone. Those interested are asked to send an abstract (200–500 words) as well as a short bio (50 words) to sauronanthology@gmail.com by 12/31/2026. All proposals will be reviewed by 2/28/2027, with the first drafts of accepted proposals due by 7/31/2027. Chapters should be 5,000 to 6,000 words in MLA format.